Hidden Pizza Shop Gems in London
London is famous for its rich culture, history, and diverse food options. Whether you’re craving traditional fish and chips, spicy Indian curry, or fresh sushi, this city has it all. But when it comes to pizza, London isn’t just about the big chains you see everywhere. Hidden across the city are small, secret pizza shops that serve delicious slices many people don’t know about. If you’re a pizza lover who wants to find unique places, here’s a guide to some hidden pizza gems in London.
Pizza Pilgrims – Carnaby’s Hidden Courtyard
Located in the lively Carnaby area, Pizza Pilgrims has become a favorite among locals. This pizza spot specializes in Neapolitan-style pizza, with soft, chewy dough and tasty toppings. But the real secret here is their outdoor courtyard seating. When you enter the shop, you might not immediately notice the cozy patio tucked away at the back. It’s a peaceful spot for enjoying their famous truffle pizza or creamy burrata starter.
What makes Pizza Pilgrims special is how creative their menu is. They’ve got dishes like the “Double Pepperoni & Spicy Honey” pizza, which fans say is unforgettable. If you’re looking for a hidden corner in the heart of London to eat pizza under fairy lights, this place won’t disappoint.
Sourdough Sophia – Crouch End’s Local Treasure
Far from central London lies a magical pizza shop called Sourdough Sophia in Crouch End. It’s the perfect spot if you want high-quality, artisanal pizza without the hustle of the busy city center. This small, independent shop has an undeniable charm, thanks to its warm staff and delicious food.
Their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients, and they only use sourdough for the crust, giving it that signature chewy texture and slight tangy flavor. One of their standout options is the “Nduja Diablo,” topped with spicy nduja and rich, gooey mozzarella. Pair that with their homemade dips, like the roasted garlic butter, and you’ll be dreaming of your next visit before you’ve finished your meal.
Santa Maria – Hidden Gem of Ealing
Ealing in West London is home to one of the best-kept pizza secrets in the city – Santa Maria. It’s not flashy or located in a touristy area, but that’s part of what makes it so special. Featuring traditional Neapolitan pizza, Santa Maria is loved for its authentic flavors and beautiful simplicity.
One of their must-try pizzas is the “San Daniele,” topped with silky Parma ham, mozzarella, and rocket. It’s a combination that tastes fresh and indulgent all at once. The small, relaxed venue makes you feel like you’ve discovered something truly unique. Plus, their wood-fired oven ensures every bite has that perfect smoky crust.
L’Antica Pizzeria da Michele – Stoke Newington’s Slice of Naples
You might have heard of L’Antica Pizzeria da Michele if you know about authentic Italian pizza. Their original shop in Naples, Italy, is world-famous, and they opened a quiet branch in Stoke Newington. This hidden gem brings centuries-old pizza traditions to London.
Unlike other pizza shops that offer lots of toppings, L’Antica keeps things simple. Their two classic options – Margherita and Marinara – are made with only the freshest ingredients. But don’t be fooled by the simplicity; the flavors are outstanding. Locals and visitors love the buttery dough and tangy tomato sauce. If you’re someone who believes less is more when it comes to pizza, this is the place for you.
Lost Boys Pizza – A Gothic Adventure in Camden
For those who want something completely different, Lost Boys Pizza in Camden is an unforgettable experience. The pizza shop is themed after the vampire movie The Lost Boys from the 1980s, and its dark, gothic vibe makes it stand out. The pizzas themselves are unusual too – the dough is black because it’s made with charcoal.
Their menu is bold, featuring quirky names like “Fangs for the Memories” and “The Garlic Crusher.” The toppings are equally bold, mixing flavors like smoked salmon, capers, and dill mascarpone. Whether you’re there for the pizza or the atmosphere, Lost Boys Pizza promises something totally unique.
Zia Lucia – Pizza for Every Taste
Hidden in various neighborhoods including Islington and Aldgate, Zia Lucia is a pizza shop that offers something different: four types of dough to choose from. You can pick traditional white, wholemeal, gluten-free, or their unique charcoal base. It’s rare to find somewhere that accommodates all dietary needs while still delivering great flavor.
Try their “Arianna” pizza, which comes with mozzarella, sausage, soft truffle honey, and pecorino cheese. It’s the perfect balance of sweet and savory. Their cozy locations and friendly vibe make Zia Lucia a favorite of locals who know where to find the city’s best pizza under the radar.
Conclusion
London may be a big city, but it’s full of small, hidden gems – especially when it comes to pizza. From cozy courtyards to gothic atmospheres, these secret spots cater to all kinds of tastes and styles. So next time you’re on the hunt for amazing pizza, skip the big names and try one of these independent treasures. It’s these lesser-known places that often create the biggest foodie memories.
What’s your favorite hidden pizza shop in London? Let us know in the comments!
